The idea behind Reese's Crunchy Cookie Peanut Butter Cups is a strong one--take America's greatest candy and sprinkle crunchy chocolate Oreo-like cookie crumbles throughout. The taste of the chocolate is drowned out by the rest of the peanut butter cup but there is a newly distinct light-as-air crunch added into every bite. But subjectively I just don't like any lumps or crunchies in my peanut butter. The smoother the better to my particular palette. These new Reese's are definitely worth a taste-test, but I am personally returning promptly to the classic Reese's.
Score (factoring personal anti-crunchy peanut butter bias): 2
Score (attempting to put personal bias aside in the name of objectivity): 3
Score (dreaming of a classic Reese's Peanut Butter Cup containing the smoothest of peanut butters): 5